Second opinion on interpretation of horary

1
I asked an astrologer ( supposedly professional ) a question:


Will I and SG sleep with each other again in the future ? Alcabitus house system.

Your representative is the 1st house and the ruler of this house is Mars, the planet of Aries. SG is in the 7th house, this house is about relationships and romantic connections. The ruler of the 7th house is Venus, because Libra is located here. The interaction between Mars and Venus clearly shows the strong sexual attraction and passion between you.

When we look at the aspect between Mars and Venus, there is a fiery and irresistible energy between you. It is very obvious that you both have a deep desire for each other. Especially the proximity of Mars to Venus shows that the sexual attraction is strong and this relationship has the potential for a physical intimacy. It's not just physical, but also the desire for each other that draws you together.

The position of the Moon in the chart indicates future events and here the Moon has an approaching aspect to Mars. This shows that your feelings and desires are directed towards the SG and that the SG is receptive to this mutual desire. The fact that this aspect is favorable and happens quickly gives a clear answer to your question.

The attraction and desire between you will bring you back together in a very short time. This reunion will also be a physical intimacy and a passionate encounter. The chart says that the answer to your question is a clear "yes". You will get back together and be together as soon as possible. To maintain this energy and fire, trust your instincts and go with the flow.

Is this done correctly and the interpretation ?
Attachments
70DC28AC-CC0F-4CEF-A91A-AC55F13A32C5.png 70DC28AC-CC0F-4CEF-A91A-AC55F13A32C5.png Viewed 5277 times 296.76 KiB

Re: Second opinion on interpretation of horary

2
Your astrologer gave you incorrect house rulers. The cusp of the 1st house (you) is in Aquarius, which is ruled by Saturn, not Mars. The cusp of the 7th (SG) is in Leo, ruled by the Sun, not Venus.

However, in spite of this, the situation looks favorable (in my less-than-expert opinion). The Moon is separating from Saturn and applying to a square to the Sun, I.e. rulers of the 1st and 7th houses getting together. When the Moon-Sun square perfects, since the Sun is exalted in Aries, you'll have reception working for you, which means the Sun will receive the aspect well. (Not as good as a trine, but could still happen.)

Here's a link to Bonatti's table of perfection, which explains how reception works. Note for a square + reception it says "Comes only through the striving and diligent pursuit of the querent." So this is going to require some effort on your part if you want it to happen.

https://www.skyscript.co.uk/perfection.html

I am not a professional astrologer or a horary expert, just a long-time student of astrology, and that's my take on it.

--stargeezer

Re: Second opinion on interpretation of horary

3
Hello,

Did the astrologer give you a copy of the chart or did you create the chart based on something else? My guess would be that the astrologer looked at a different chart than what we are seeing here (based on the information in the text not matching the chart). I did once ask a horary reader many, many years ago a question and they interpreted a sextile as a square and it changed their interpretation after I corrected them. I've never seen a professional be this wrong so I would give them the benefit of the doubt without more info. Maybe send them a message to clarify the chart data.