Re: Beyond the Seasonal Metaphor - Aristotle's On Generation and Corruption

25
I instinctively rely on seasonal metaphors when thinking of the zodiac signs, as someone living in the northern hemisphere, where astrology mainly developed. The seasons in the northern hemisphere match the natures of the zodiac signs very well, such as tropical Aries - assertive, youthful, and boisterous - coinciding with lively spring. The seasons supplement or complement the tropical zodiac, I guess.
However, as we all know, the seasons in the southern hemisphere are reversed, and different countries in the same hemisphere don’t experience the seasons at the same time or the same way.
And Antarctica only has two seasons.

That’s why I said tropical Aries coincides with spring in the northern hemisphere.
I think the tropical zodiac is tied to the equinoxes and solstices, not the seasons. No matter where you live, in late March, the Sun crosses the celestial equator and rises north, out of the metaphysical underworld, which is south of the celestial equator. I think this correlates more strongly to the Sun’s exaltation in Aries than the season of spring does.

The equinoxes and solstices may correlate with the seasons, but they’re not tied to them, I don’t think. That’s why I’m open to a reinterpretation of the tropical zodiac that doesn’t rely on the seasons.

Patrick Watson wrote an interesting article in 2018 where he addresses the tropical zodiac’s hemisphere problem. Our solar system is not alone in our galaxy, and is orbiting the centre of the Milky Way Galaxy. With this knowledge, Patrick Watson suggests that the northern hemisphere is “special” because:
Using our solar system’s movement around the Milky Way galaxy as our point of reference, what we consider Earth’s “North” is really the Solar System’s “Front”, and Earth’s “South” is really the Solar System’s “Behind”. Our solar apex (the direction the sun is heading through the galaxy) is currently just southwest of the northern star Vega. So Earth’s northern hemisphere is generally the front seat of our voyage around the Milky Way.

What’s important about this is it means our idea of North isn’t totally arbitrary. The concepts of “above” and “front” are distinct but closely related, far more closely connected to each other than either are to the concepts of “below” or “behind”. If our solar system were actually moving in the direction that our southern hemisphere was facing, then I think it would be fair to say that we’ve got it all completely backwards. In that case we’d be saying what’s “North” or “up” is the opposite direction of where our solar system is moving. Instead, what we’ve collectively decided North is also just happens to be the direction our whole solar system is heading toward. Even if you flipped the galaxy upside down, our solar system would still be moving in the direction we recognize as “North” on our planet. I think that’s significant.

This lends an astronomical basis for the vernal equinox in March to be considered the start of the zodiac, as the northern hemisphere is pointing in the direction the solar system as a whole is facing and moving. Viewing the equinoxes and solstices relative to the galactic plane globalizes the interpretation of the equinoxes so that they equally apply to both hemispheres. Seasonal variations between the hemispheres can add another layer of interpretation to the signs without changing their sects, modes, elements or rulerships. I mean, that’s pretty good news right?
But let me know what you guys think.

Re: Beyond the Seasonal Metaphor - Aristotle's On Generation and Corruption

27
Hi everyone - many thanks for the contributions so far. This is an extremely helpful discussion.
Patrick Watson wrote an interesting article in 2018 where he addresses the tropical zodiac’s hemisphere problem.
Thanks Mr Gallows. Dare I say that it might give us something to hang the whole discussion on. This is a very helpful article and might point a way forward!

I will try and summarise the key points from the posts soon into a single reply.

Apologies for the delay in transmission. I have been a way from my desk for a while.

Best wishes to all. Ed
"...the motions that are akin to the divine in us are the thoughts and revolutions of the universe."

Plato, Timaeus, 90.