I saw a TV Prog (In Pakistan), a horary astrologer by the name of Mamoo Gee was answering different people with the help of one chart (hand drawn). But whenever he was answering another person, he turned a chart to take a different ascendant from the same chart. His answer for relationship horaries was not same for different people. Now, if we use same chart than 1-7 questions should have similar sort of answer.

I was going through a book Raheem ul Wuktee Zaicha. The author suggests a method (not his own) in which if a horary astrologer is being visited by different people at a same time, he changes the position of ascendant for each person. Like


Normal chart for first client.

The position of Sun in first chart would become ascendant for second client.

The Position of Moon in first chart would become ascendant for third client and so on for other planets.


My question is, how would we encounter a situation. Let us suppose a TV prog. In which we are invited and are answering people on-line. If we use normal rules and answer for 1-7 question is not positive, it seems that asnwer would be same for all the people asking the same sort of question in that little time frame. It is worth mentioning that relationship horaries constitute major portion of questions asked.

P.s I know that Lilly used one chart to answer two people in his CA. But what about answering more people with the help of same chart

The late Barbara Watters answers this very question in her book on Horary Astrology: she says that one chart can be used to answer several different questions asked at the same time, but of course the same chart can give different answers depending on the house and planetary rulers signifying the quesited.