Character analysis questions in horary?

1
Guys,

Do you think it's legit to use horaries to ask questions about a particular persons psychological profile, or is that best left to natal analysis?

I have a horary chart where the querent asks if the quesitted has violent or sado-masochistic sexual tendencies. (January 24, 2005, 1:56 am, New York City). The natal chart of the quesitted certainly shows such possibility. But does the horary? In the horary Mars is closely applying to conjunction with Pluto in the quesitted's turned 8th House. Also in the turned/derived 8th is Mercury conj. Venus in Capricorn, opposite Saturn conj. Moon in the turned 2nd, and square Jupiter.

Hmmm... I wanna dismiss this as an illegitimate question for horary, and yet the horary chart seems to answer the question quite clearly -- or am I missing something.

Do you guys think this kind of interpretation works?

PL

2
I think the question can be answered (But I'm not going to venture a judgment). I recall a question in John Frawley's horary course about the suitablity of a potential nanny. If you can do that, why not this?

I'm interested in hearing other's views.

Tom