veritas wrote:I just don't like the idea that I am imprisoned by my own fate and there is nothing I can do about it.

No matter what direction I will go. Makes me feel like a caged animal. Maybe I should have never asked about all this.

What about constellations like the Grand Water trine? Is this a too general aspect to have any kind of impact on me or another individual?

Well, we're definitely not as 'free' as many of us would like to think.
Life does have an astoundingly easy job in showing us our own impotence time and time again and that makes one wonder...

Oh yes, the Grand water/airy/fire whatever... that's nothing more than one of those countless, sweet sounding but meaningless labels designed by some self-proclaimed astrology expert in order to facilitate the selling of his books to astrologically uneducated public.

Sorry, but there are just so many charlatans out there who don't have a clue about what astrology really is and how it was conceived to function/be applied.
You need to be very careful in what you read if you want to get to the heart of the matter

Goran

Sorry, but there are just so many charlatans out there who don't have a clue about what astrology really is and how it was conceived to function.

I wouldn't dismiss it so fast. It's like saying Uranus/Pluto square is also only a charlatan act.

By the way, I 've sent you two PM.

veritas wrote:

Sorry, but there are just so many charlatans out there who don't have a clue about what astrology really is and how it was conceived to function.

I wouldn't dismiss it so fast. It's like saying Uranus/Pluto square is also only a charlatan act.

By the way, I 've sent you two PM.

But I would, gladly.

I never used these elements in my delineation and haven't missed a thing because of that. And as far as real astrology is concerned, this combination does represent a charlatan act. It surely isn't "politically correct" to say such a thing, but it's nevertheless true.

Just for the record, I've acquainted myself very well with all kinds of charlatanism out there before turning to astrology I practice today very successfully so I know first hand what I'm talking about. There was a time, long gone now, when I learned and tried to use this kind of charlatan stuff...

But this is not the place to discuss this matter any further nor is it my intention to do so.

I never got any notifications for these PMs

Goran

Hi veritas,

You have asked horary questions because you want to know about something and the desire to know has been consuming you for some time. No matter how good some of the members have been in their analysis there are following constraints

1. They were not astrologers of the horary. Responsibility for finding a definite answer is actually yours.

2. They can not act in a professional capacity. Professional consultation is slightly different.

3. They dont know about conditions existing in your life right now as fully as you do. Context of the question is extremely important. You have to make an effort to understand the 'Cold readings' and adapt to your own circumstances existing right now.

4. You have to keep in mind that we all observe a same thing but our way of expressing it is slightly different.

4. Every great opportunity hides behind a tiresome boring hard work. Thats why Hard aspects shown in Solar charts are not bad things.

1. They were not astrologers of the horary. Responsibility for finding a definite answer is actually yours.

I know.

2. They can not act in a professional capacity. Professional consultation is slightly different

.

Professional consultation is kind of overrated in my opinion. I had several of them, and the all kind of failed to impress me. I got better answers here on the board.

3. They dont know about conditions existing in your life right now as fully as you do. Context of the question is extremely important. You have to make an effort to understand the 'Cold readings' and adapt to your own circumstances existing right now.

I have learned that Cold readings are better than giving away all of your personal details. Lots of astrologers adapt to the information you give them and the result is kind of mixed.

4. You have to keep in mind that we all observe a same thing but our way of expressing it is slightly different.

Which is why I am here. To get different approaches, POVs.

4. Every great opportunity hides behind a tiresome boring hard work. Thats why Hard aspects shown in Solar charts are not bad things.

Unless you lose a lot of money

Quote:
4. You have to keep in mind that we all observe a same thing but our way of expressing it is slightly different.


Which is why I am here. To get different approaches, POVs.

I got an impression that perhaps you were not satisfied. . Misunderstanding on my part.